The 5th Amendment of the United States Constitution gives a criminal defendant the right to choose not to testify at trial. Often people wonder why anyone would choose to do this, and it is common for criminal defendants to want to take the stand and tell their story to the jury. Unfortunately, while taking the stand may seem like a great idea, especially to someone who is innocent, there are many reasons why it is often better not to take the stand at trial. Taking the stand can easily provide an opportunity for the defendant to appear much more culpable than he actually is. This is why the 5th Amendment right to not testify is sometimes referred to as the right against self-incrimination.
When a criminal defendant takes the stand, all types of information can come into court that otherwise would never have been heard by the jury. Despite the high burdens of proof in a criminal trial, juries are often very subjective in their decision making, and can easily be influenced by a defendant’s demeanor, language, or any of the potentially negative information that can come into court once the defendant decides to take the stand. Once a defendant takes the stand at trial, the prosecution may tell the jury about past crimes the defendant has been convicted of. Additionally, the prosecution may be able to put people on the stand that can testify as to their negative opinions of the defendant’s reputation. This is information that would not be heard by the jury if the defendant chose not to take the stand.
Additionally, the jury is not allowed to infer anything negative from the fact that the defendant does not testify, and the prosecution is not allowed to comment on it. In sum, there are very good reasons why an attorney may persuade a defendant not to take the stand and any defendant should carefully consider this advice. Even though not taking the stand may seem counter intuitive, it is often the best choice.
For more information on Drug Charges, visit my website Anthony N. Palumbo, New Jersey Defense attorney at www.palumbo-renaud.com/PracticeAreas/Other-Drug-Offenses.asp